What is one to say, that has not already been said, of the December 18th response to the eleven dubia, raised in light of Traditionis Custodes? There is the intriguing swiftness of the brusque and brutal directives, in contrast to the still-unaswered dubia of Amoris Laetitia, a half decade on.

There are calls for open defiance, to ignoring the law, to careful discernment in the Holy Spirit, to invoking Canon law, or all of the above. Here are just a few thoughts: The dubia following upon Amoris had to do with fundamental moral principles, without the keeping of which, we cannot attain heaven. Yet unlike Christ’s clear and direct reply to the rich young man – keep the Commandments! – the lack of a reaffirmation of Christ’s clarion call leaves one free floating.

On the contrary, the recent dubia had to do with disciplinary matters of Liturgy, and, here, the Magisterium responds clearly and swiftly, leaving no room for doubt: The pre-conciliar Liturgy must be isolated, and allowed to die from sheer attrition, even strangulation.

One may think they have their priorities out of order, but, upon deeper reflection, perhaps not. There are three aspects to living out the Christian path: Lex orandi, lex credendi and lex vivendi. The law of praying, the law of believing and the law of living, in that order. We live, as we believe, and we believe, as we pray.

In other words, prayer comes first. And the highest form of prayer, is the Liturgy. And the source and summit of the Liturgy, is the holy sacrifice of the Mass. The Mass is the primary link between this world and the next, earth and heaven, how we celebrate and pray at Mass shapes, forms and directs everything else, in life, in society, in the world.

There was some development required after the Council, but even a brief perusal of the minimal tweaks called for by the constitution Sacrosanctum Concilium shows they went too far. And praxis – the way the Mass is actually celebrated – has gone even farther still.

Hence, Benedict XVI urged the traditional Mass to inform the Novus Ordo, to provide a lodestone and exemplar, to keep the New Mass on the right track. It is still possible – and to my mind, ideal – to celebrate the new Mass a lot like the old Mass, ad orientem, the Roman canon, with proper chants, even in Latin.

Yes, one rarely, if ever, sees that – the aptly, if sadly, termed ‘unicorn Mass’’, which is a big part of the problem, one which may only get worse if the Old Mass (mostly) disappears. What will hold the centre together then?

Whatever path we choose, or are able to choose, the Liturgy is God’s work, and we must trust in Him to see that the Mass of the ages will never go away – underground, perhaps, kept alive here and there, like sparks amongst the worldly stubble. Its beauty and glory will somehow survive these travails and trials.

 

The post Amoris, Traditionis and the Dubia appeared first on Catholic Insight.